CPT code 23410 – Open repair of acute rotator cuff tear
23410 is the CPT code for repair of ruptured musculotendinous cuff (eg, rotator cuff) open; acute. It covers open surgical repair of a recently torn rotator cuff through a formal incision.
Coders most often stumble on this code at two decision points. The first is choosing between 23410 (acute) and 23412 (chronic) when documentation is ambiguous. The second is telling the open approach apart from arthroscopic CPT 29827.
- Section
- 10004-69990 Surgery
- Subsection
- 20100-29999 Musculoskeletal system
- Code range
- 23395-23491 Repair, revision, and/or reconstruction procedures on the shoulder
- Billable
- No
- Code also known as
- open rotator cuff surgery, acute rotator cuff repair, shoulder tendon repair
Let Pabau's smart automation suggest the right codes, reduce claim denials, and keep your practice compliant—effortlessly.
- AI-powered code suggestions
- Real-time compliance checks
- Faster claims, fewer denials
Automate repetitive tasks and focus on what matters most—your patients.
Reduce coding errors and ensure compliance with the latest regulations.
Clean claims, fewer denials, and faster reimbursements.
Powerful insights and reporting to help your practice thrive.
HIPAA compliant SOC 2 certified GDPR-compliant Trusted by 4,000+ clinics worldwide
Key takeaways
CPT code 23410 covers open repair of a ruptured rotator cuff in the acute phase. Chronic tears bill under 23412, and arthroscopic repairs under 29827.
Documentation must establish acuity. Operative notes should describe fresh tendon tissue, hemorrhage, or a clinical history of sudden-onset injury.
Most payers require modifier LT or RT for laterality, and a missing one is a common denial reason for shoulder surgery codes.
In 2026, 23410 carries 11.11 work RVUs and 22.90 total facility RVUs, slightly less than the chronic code 23412.
Pabau’s claims management tracks the prior authorization on the patient’s case and sends US claims through Claim.MD with eligibility checks and ERA remittances.
CPT code 23410: Official descriptor and quick-reference data
CPT code 23410 is the code for open repair of a ruptured rotator cuff in the acute phase.
CMS’s 2026 relative value file lists it as “Repair rotator cuff acute,” a 90-day global surgery with 11.11 work RVUs.
The code sits in the musculoskeletal section of the AMA CPT code set, in the 23395-23491 range for shoulder repair, revision, and reconstruction. The official descriptor reads: Repair of ruptured musculotendinous cuff (eg, rotator cuff) open; acute.
The AMA maintains the CPT code set and publishes the official descriptor annually. For the authoritative descriptor and any coding guidelines specific to 23410, consult the AMA’s CPT code set overview.
Surgical technique and documentation requirements for CPT 23410
Open rotator cuff repair uses a deltoid-splitting or deltoid-detaching incision that exposes the supraspinatus and, when involved, the infraspinatus tendon. The surgeon debrides frayed tissue, prepares the tuberosity footprint, and reattaches the torn tendon with suture anchors or transosseous tunnels.
The repair counts as open because the surgeon sees the repair site directly through a formal incision, not through arthroscopic portals.
What the operative report must establish for the claim to be payable:
- Acuity of the tear: Fresh hemorrhagic tissue, lack of fatty infiltration, and a clinical history consistent with sudden-onset injury. Payers audit this detail when 23410 is billed for a patient with a long pre-operative symptom history.
- Extent of the tear: The descriptor covers a ruptured cuff, so document the extent of the tear. Payers expect the note to say whether the rupture is full-thickness and how far it runs across the tendon.
- Open approach: State the incision type, length, and that direct visualization occurred. Mini-open repairs may qualify as 23410 when the open dissection extends to the tendon repair site, though payer policies on this vary. Verify with the specific payer before billing.
- Specific tendon(s) involved: Name the supraspinatus, infraspinatus, subscapularis, or teres minor as repaired. This supports both code selection and medical necessity.
- Laterality: Document left or right shoulder explicitly. Missing laterality in the operative note is a downstream cause of modifier omissions on the claim.
- Medical necessity: Conservative treatment failure or acute traumatic rupture requiring surgery. Prior imaging (MRI) results confirming the tear should be referenced.
CPT 23410 vs 23412: Acute vs chronic rotator cuff repair
The acute/chronic distinction is a frequent coding question for this code family. CPT 23412 describes open repair of a chronic rotator cuff tear. The surgical approach is the same, but the clinical presentation differs.
The AMA does not define a strict timeframe separating acute from chronic. What matters is what the operative note describes. A patient with six months of symptoms who sustains an acute-on-chronic tear with documented fresh hemorrhage could still support 23410. The documentation drives the code selection, never the other way around.
The decision path below shows how the approach, then the operative findings, narrow the choice to one code and one diagnosis pairing.

One more factor sits upstream of acuity. The surgical approach decides whether the 23400 series applies at all.
Open vs arthroscopic rotator cuff repair: Coding implications for CPT 29827
CPT 29827 describes arthroscopic rotator cuff repair. The two codes are mutually exclusive for the same shoulder, because the approach determines code selection, not tear severity or repair complexity.
Related shoulder repair codes: 23412, 23420, 23430, and the 23400 series
These are the shoulder codes most often confused with, or billed alongside, CPT code 23410.
ICD-10 codes to pair with CPT 23410
A mismatched diagnosis code is a common denial reason for CPT code 23410, alongside missing laterality modifiers. The ICD-10-CM codes you pair with it must reflect an acute injury, not a degenerative process, to support medical necessity for the acute repair.
Laterality in the ICD-10 code and the CPT modifier must match. A right-shoulder S46.011A paired with modifier LT is a laterality conflict. Most clearinghouses catch it on edit, but some claims pass through and deny at the payer level. If the operative note describes a degenerative tear instead, M75.121 or M75.122 points the claim toward 23412. For official ICD-10-CM code lookup and guidance, the CDC/NCHS ICD-10-CM web tool is the authoritative US reference.
Prior authorization requirements for open rotator cuff repair
Most commercial insurers and Medicare Advantage plans require prior authorization for shoulder surgery. Traditional Medicare (Parts A and B) generally does not require it for CPT 23410. Medicaid requirements vary by state and managed care organization.
- Medicare Advantage: Most MA plans require prior authorization for elective orthopedic surgery. Submit the operative plan, imaging reports confirming the tear, and documentation of conservative treatment failure (physical therapy, corticosteroid injections).
- Commercial insurers: Prior auth is standard. Required documents typically include the treating physician’s letter of medical necessity, MRI report, and functional assessment showing impairment.
- Retro-authorization: Emergency or urgent cases may qualify for retrospective authorization, but most elective rotator cuff repairs do not. Never assume retro-auth will be granted; pursue prospective auth whenever possible.
- Denial for missing auth: Claims denied for missing prior authorization are typically not appealable on clinical grounds. They require a retro-auth request or administrative appeal. Prevention is significantly more efficient than remedy.
Payer-specific prior authorization requirements change frequently. Always verify the patient’s plan-specific requirements before scheduling elective shoulder surgery.
Pro Tip
Before scheduling open rotator cuff repair, run an insurance eligibility check and confirm prior auth requirements for the specific plan. Document the authorization number on the claim and in the patient record. For Medicare Advantage patients, check the plan’s list of codes requiring auth — many plans publish a searchable tool. A single missed auth step on a 23410 claim can hold up reimbursement for weeks.
Medicare reimbursement and RVU values for CPT 23410
Medicare pays CPT code 23410 from the Physician Fee Schedule, using three RVU components: work, practice expense, and malpractice. Each component is adjusted by a Geographic Practice Cost Index (GPCI) for the payment locality, then multiplied by the annual conversion factor.
At the 2026 conversion factor of $33.4009, 22.90 RVUs come to roughly $765 before locality adjustment. The chronic code 23412 carries 11.63 work RVUs and 23.70 total facility RVUs, so coding acute on thin documentation earns no extra payment.
Dollar amounts move with the annual conversion factor and locality adjustments. The CMS Physician Fee Schedule lookup tool provides current rates by locality, year, and place of service. For a free RVU calculator that imports current CMS data and applies GPCI multipliers, FastRVU’s 2026 lookup is a useful reference. The figures above come from the CMS July 2026 relative value file. Always pull current-year rates from the official CMS tool before billing or quoting reimbursement to physicians.
Global surgical package and post-op billing for CPT 23410
CPT 23410 carries a 90-day global surgical period under CMS. Routine pre-operative and post-operative services within that window are bundled into the procedure payment. Billing separately for included services is a compliance risk.
What is bundled into the 90-day global period:
- All post-operative E&M visits related to the surgery and its complications
- Suture removal, wound checks, and routine dressing changes
- Post-operative physical therapy referral management (not the PT itself, which bills separately)
- The day before and day of the surgery (included in the global package)
What can be billed separately within the global period:
- Modifier 24: Unrelated E&M visit during the global period (e.g. patient presents with an unrelated illness)
- Modifier 78: Return to the operating room for a complication related to the original procedure
- Modifier 79: Unrelated procedure performed during the global period on a different site
- Modifier 58: Staged or related procedure planned at the time of the original surgery
Modifiers commonly used with CPT 23410
Modifier selection for CPT code 23410 affects both payment and compliance. The laterality modifier matters most, and it is also a frequent omission.
Common denial reasons for CPT 23410 and how to resolve them
Open rotator cuff repair claims deny for predictable reasons. Each one traces back to a specific root cause in the claim or the operative note.
Bundling rules and NCCI edits for CPT 23410
The National Correct Coding Initiative (NCCI) publishes quarterly edits that determine which procedure code pairs are considered bundled by CMS. For CPT code 23410, bundling most commonly affects ancillary shoulder procedures performed on the same day.
Key NCCI bundling principles for 23410:
- Surgical approach codes are always bundled. The incision and exposure required to reach the rotator cuff are part of the 23410 work and cannot be billed separately.
- Subacromial decompression: Check 29826 or 23130 against the current NCCI tables whenever either accompanies an open repair. Edit status changes quarterly.
- Unbundling with modifier 59: This is only appropriate for two distinct services at separate anatomical sites or in separate sessions. Circumstances genuinely outside the bundling intent also qualify. Routine application of modifier 59 to override a bundling edit without documentation is a compliance violation.
- NCCI tables change quarterly. Verify any edit pair in the current quarter’s NCCI Policy Manual before billing or appealing. CMS publishes them on its NCCI edits page. Practices using structured denial management workflows catch NCCI-related denials faster by logging edit type and resolution steps per claim.
How claims management software reduces denials for CPT 23410
Most 23410 denials start before the claim leaves the practice. A laterality modifier is left off, an M75 code rides on an acute repair, or the prior authorization number never reaches the claim. Billing teams often learn about it weeks later, on the remittance.
Pabau, the practice management platform we build, keeps the surgical case and the claim in one record. Its claims management software tracks the authorization code, dates, and sessions on the patient’s case, and warns staff when one is missing.

US claims go out as CMS-1500/837P through Claim.MD, our Claim.MD clearinghouse partner. Eligibility checks run before the surgery date, and ERA remittances tie each payment back to its original claim.
Stop chasing 23410 denials after they happen
Pabau tracks prior authorizations on the case and sends US claims through Claim.MD. Eligibility checks and ERA remittances cut the rework on denied claims.

Conclusion
For CPT code 23410, the operative note decides the claim. When the surgeon records fresh hemorrhage, viable tissue, and the side, the code, the S46.01- diagnosis, and the modifier all follow from it.
Remember that 23410 pays slightly less than 23412. Choosing the acute code on thin documentation buys no revenue and invites an audit, so code to what the note supports.
Book a demo to see how Pabau keeps prior authorizations, claims, and remittances for orthopedic surgery in one workflow.
Continue your research
Need a clearinghouse that catches modifier errors automatically? Pabau’s Claim.MD clearinghouse guide explains how real-time claim validation works across 4,000+ US payers.
Seeing recurring denial patterns across your orthopedic claims? Denial management in healthcare covers root-cause workflows to reduce rework systematically.
Want to understand how claims flow from submission to ERA? Electronic remittance advice (ERA) explains 835 file processing and how ERA ties payments back to original claims.
Frequently asked questions
What does CPT code 23410 cover?
CPT code 23410 covers open surgical repair of a ruptured (acute) rotator cuff. The surgeon uses a formal open incision, not arthroscopic portals, to directly visualize and reattach a recently torn tendon, typically the supraspinatus or infraspinatus.
What is the difference between CPT 23410 and CPT 23412?
CPT 23410 is for acute rotator cuff tears with fresh hemorrhagic tissue and minimal retraction. CPT 23412 is for chronic tears with degenerative changes, fatty infiltration, and significant retraction. The intraoperative findings in the operative report determine which code applies, not the symptom duration alone.
What is the Medicare reimbursement rate for CPT 23410?
Medicare reimbursement varies by payment locality and changes annually with the conversion factor. In the 2026 fee schedule, 23410 carries 11.11 work RVUs and 22.90 total facility RVUs. Use the CMS Physician Fee Schedule lookup tool for current rates in your locality.
What modifiers are required with CPT 23410?
Most payers, including CMS, require modifier LT (left) or RT (right), and a missing one is a common denial cause. Modifier 51 covers multiple procedures on the same date, and 59 unbundles a genuinely distinct service. Modifier 78 marks an unplanned return to the OR.
Can CPT 23410 and 23412 be billed together?
No. CPT 23410 and 23412 describe the same procedure on the same structure and differ only in acuity. Only one repair code applies per shoulder per operative session. Billing both on the same date for the same shoulder is a duplicate-service edit that payers will reject.
What is the global surgery period for CPT 23410?
CPT 23410 has a 90-day global surgical period under Medicare. Routine post-operative E&M visits, wound checks, and complication management related to the original surgery are bundled into the procedure payment for 90 days. Unrelated services and return-to-OR complications can be billed separately with appropriate modifiers (24, 78, 79).
What ICD-10 codes should be paired with CPT 23410?
The primary ICD-10 pairings for CPT 23410 are S46.011A (right shoulder, initial encounter) and S46.012A (left shoulder, initial encounter). Both are the traumatic rotator cuff injury codes. Avoid M75.121 and M75.122 (complete tears not specified as traumatic) with 23410, as they trigger acute/chronic mismatch denials.



